Horror Game Awards 2026: Tito’s Picks & Predictions

Mayu from Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Remake surrounded by glowing red butterflies under a night sky, with the title Horror Game Awards 2026: Tito's Picks & Predictions

Some people get the Christmas lights up in September. Me? A horror awards show in November is enough to make me happy.

The Horror Game Awards 2026 happens on Friday, November 20, which is the wee hours of Saturday here in the Philippines. That’s exactly the right time to watch horror. Other sites have already posted the nominee list, so I won’t just copy it. This post is all about the big one, Horror Game of the Year: who I think will win, who I want to win, the snub, the dark horse, and how we can play the nominees here at home.

Quick honesty check: I haven’t played most of this year’s nominees. My predictions come from the nominations, sales, and player reviews. My picks come from the gut of a guy who has been getting scared by games since the PS1 rental-shop days. Some of those scares are still with me, as you can see in my list of jump scares that traumatized me.

Credit: Nomination counts come from Horror Obsessive’s breakdown. Official details are at The Horror Game Awards.


Quick Facts

Date Friday, Nov 20, 2026, 7:00 PM GMT
Philippine time Saturday, Nov 21, 3:00 AM PHT
Venue 26 Leake Street, Waterloo, London
Categories 21 (5 new)
Most nominations REANIMAL 10 · Resident Evil Requiem 9 · Silent Hill: Townfall, Hellraiser: Revival, Silver Pines 8 each

The 5 nominations for Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Remake are unconfirmed.


Horror Game of the Year

There are 16 nominees: REANIMAL, Resident Evil Requiem, Silent Hill: Townfall, Hellraiser: Revival, Silver Pines, Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Remake, The Blood of Dawnwalker, Directive 8020, Endacopia, Heaven Does Not Respond, No Means Nothing, Offering App, Project Songbird, ROUTINE, The Skin Stapler, and Tenebris Somnia.

🎯 Tito’s Prediction: REANIMAL

Here’s why I think the HGA Claw goes to Tarsier:

  • It leads the whole field. Ten nominations, including Best Art Direction and Best Soundtrack. When a jury loves a game in that many categories, it loves the whole package.
  • Other juries already agree. REANIMAL won a horror narrative and direction award at Japan’s Horror Game Awards 2026, on top of a design award back home in Sweden.
  • It’s a brand-new IP. Most of its competition is sequels, remakes and licensed games. REANIMAL is the big original horror game of the year, from the team that made Little Nightmares.
  • It sold. Over 1 million copies in three months is huge for a new game that isn’t attached to a famous franchise.

The catch is that Steam players are cooler on it, at around 74% “Mostly Positive.” Juries reward craft more than popularity, though. Also remember that last year Silent Hill f won after tying for the most nominations, so the number alone doesn’t guarantee anything.

❤️ Tito’s Pick: Silent Hill: Townfall

Silent Hill: Townfall key visual of Simon looking down at the CRTV device in a foggy, red-lit street
Image: SILENT HILL: Townfall ©Konami Digital Entertainment ©Annapurna Interactive ©Screen Burn. Official press asset.

Full disclosure: I’m biased, because I’m in love with this series. But I love that the team tried to innovate instead of just repeating the past. There’s the CRTV, a TV/phone/radio device that puts a fresh spin on that classic static dread. And the game is set in a town outside Silent Hill itself, but it still keeps the atmosphere that makes it feel like Silent Hill. That’s a hard balance to pull off.

My history with this series goes back to 1999. I was browsing for a game to buy when the vendor handed me Silent Hill and told me it was a different kind of horror from Resident Evil. I bought his sales pitch, and the intro movie alone blew away my idea that it was just another Resident Evil clone. Silent Hill 3 made me so paranoid that I almost never finished it once I reached the Haunted House Tour. And yes, I’ll always stand by Silent Hill 4: The Room as the scariest in the franchise. I go deeper into all of this in Silent Hill: Why Players Still Love It.

Can it actually win? Honestly, probably not. Critics like it (81 on Metacritic), but it’s “Mixed” on Steam because of PC performance problems. Konami has confirmed a patch is coming.

🥈 Runner-up Pick: Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Remake

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Remake key visual with the game logo beside a close-up of Mayu's face
Image: FATAL FRAME II: Crimson Butterfly REMAKE © KOEI TECMO GAMES. Official press asset.

I played the original on the PS2, and here’s a confession: for me, it was the least scary game in the series. What won me over was the story. It’s more coherent and better told than the first game’s. I haven’t played the remake yet, but seeing Fatal Frame up for Game of the Year next to Resident Evil and Silent Hill already feels like a win. My full Fatal Frame obsession is in my Fatal Frame III review.


The Snub and the Dark Horse

The snub: Fatal Frame II Remake’s total. If it really only has five nominations, that’s low for a remake of one of Japan’s most important horror games. (The five-nomination count is unconfirmed.)

The dark horse: Silver Pines. A five-person team at Wych Elm made a game that sold 100,000+ copies in its first week, sits at “Overwhelmingly Positive” on Steam, and earned 8 nominations, the same as Silent Hill and Hellraiser. It’s in the Game of the Year lineup next to Capcom and Konami. If the jury wants an underdog story, this is it.


Where to Play in the Philippines

Game Platforms PH price (approx.)
REANIMAL PS5, Xbox Series, Switch 2, PC ~₱1,895 (PS5, DataBlitz / Game One)
Resident Evil Requiem PS5, Xbox Series, PC, Switch 2 ~₱3,295 (PS5, Game One / iTech / Gamextreme)
Fatal Frame II Remake PS5, Xbox Series, Switch 2, PC ~₱2,250 (PS5 Asian, DataBlitz)
Silent Hill: Townfall PS5, PC (Steam, Epic) ~₱2,795 (PS5 Asian, DataBlitz / Gamextreme)
Hellraiser: Revival PS5, Xbox Series, PC ~₱2,395 (PS5 Day One Edition, DataBlitz)

Physical retail prices as of Nov 16, 2026. Check before you buy.

  • Digital: The PS Store, eShop and Steam all have peso pricing. Steam regional pricing is usually the cheapest way to get the indie nominees.
  • Physical: Look for Asian (R3) versions at DataBlitz, Game One, iTech and Gamextreme.
  • PC players: Steam reviews mention stutter in Fatal Frame II Remake and performance problems in Townfall, so check for patches first.
  • Used: Carousell is the modern rental shop.
  • Watching the show: Set your alarm for 3:00 AM, Saturday, Nov 21.

Your Turn

That’s my ballot. My head says REANIMAL, and my heart, as always, says Silent Hill. What’s your Horror Game of the Year pick, and is Silver Pines your dark horse too? Drop it in the comments, and let’s see who called it after November 20.

— Tito Gamer


Sources: Horror Obsessive · The Horror Game Awards · Bloody Disgusting · Dread Central · GameBusiness.jp · Twisted Voxel

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *